Guides N' That

Squirrel Hill Cafe

 
4.6
 
0.0 (0)
809 0 5 0
Squirrel Hill Cafe  - April 2024 (AcrossPittsburgh) - -01

Location

Address
5802 Forbes Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15217
City Neighborhood
Add the exact City Neighborhood if you like. (e.g., Point Breeze, Garfield, etc.)

Contact

The Squirrel Hill Cafe is a neighborhood bar located along Forbes Ave. in the Squirrel Hill neighborhood of Pittsburgh. 

About The Squirrel Hill Cafe

The Squirrel Hill Cafe, affectionately known as "The Cage" to locals, stands as a beloved staple in Pittsburgh’s Squirrel Hill neighborhood. This historic bar, nestled at 5802 Forbes Avenue, has been serving patrons for decades, offering a cozy retreat with an old-school Pittsburgh charm that’s both inviting and unpretentious.

Atmosphere

The Squirrel Hill Cafe exudes a casual, laid-back vibe that makes everyone feel at home. Its interiors, characterized by dim lighting and vintage decor, create a warm ambiance that's perfect for a relaxed night out. The bar is often filled with friendly faces, from college students to long-time regulars, all enjoying the congenial atmosphere that this neighborhood bar famously provides.

Menu

The cafe is renowned not just for its drinks but for its satisfying pub fare. Patrons can enjoy perfectly cooked cheeseburgers, chicken sandwiches, and crispy bacon, which are mainstays on the menu.

The Squirrel Hill Cafe is also known for its draft beer selection, offering a variety of choices that go perfectly with any meal. For those who prefer non-alcoholic options, the cafe serves great coffee among other beverages, making it a versatile spot for any time of day.

Staff and Service

The service at Squirrel Hill Cafe is as memorable as its food and drinks. The staff are known for their efficiency and friendliness, contributing significantly to the cafe’s welcoming feel. Some staff members have been part of the cafe for decades, adding a personal touch to the service and often knowing patrons by name.

Cultural Impact

Squirrel Hill Cafe isn’t just a place to eat and drink; it's a community gathering spot that has stood the test of time. It's a place where new friends meet and old ones reunite, offering a slice of Pittsburgh's rich cultural tapestry in the heart of one of its most vibrant neighborhoods.

Whether you’re looking for a spot to unwind after work, catch up with friends, or simply enjoy a good meal and a drink, Squirrel Hill Cafe offers a timeless charm that captures the essence of Pittsburgh’s neighborhood camaraderie. It remains a cherished venue in the Squirrel Hill community, where every visit feels like coming home.

Photos

Squirrel Hill Cafe  - April 2024 (AcrossPittsburgh) - -43
Squirrel Hill Cafe  - April 2024 (AcrossPittsburgh) - -44
Squirrel Hill Cafe  - April 2024 (AcrossPittsburgh) - -41
Squirrel Hill Cafe  - April 2024 (AcrossPittsburgh) - -42

Map

Swap Start/End

Editor review

1 review
An Unexpected Evening of Burgers and Banter at Squirrel Hill Cafe
(Updated: November 26, 2024)
Overall rating
 
4.6
Drinks
 
4.0
Atmosphere
 
5.0
Service
 
5.0
Pricing
 
5.0
Location
 
4.0
On a temperate Thursday evening, I found myself venturing into Pittsburgh’s Squirrel Hill neighborhood to meet Timmy O, affectionately dubbed "Our Man In The East End." Unfortunately, plans fell through, but never one to waste a good evening, I decided to explore the vibrant local scene on my own. My first stop was Hidden Harbor, an eclectically pleasant tiki bar, where I struck up an engaging conversation with an economics TA that lasted over an hour.

As the night progressed, my stomach led me to a place affectionately known as "The Cage" by locals, but formally called the Squirrel Hill Cafe. Starving and ready for some classic pub grub, I ordered the bacon cheeseburger with a side of onion rings—dishes that were the stuff of culinary dreams. The food was absolutely delicious, satisfying in a way that only great bar food can be.

Despite dining alone, I wasn't lonely for long. To my left, I chatted with a freshly graduated college student embarking on a career in digital media. To my right, a twice-divorced man in his late 30s shared his life’s trials, including a lingering frustration that made him wish he could punch a-holes in the face. I offered some brotherly advice, suggesting he not give up on love, as the third time might just be the charm. After all, I mused, I’m still with my first wife after more than twenty years, so maybe there’s hope for everyone.

The Squirrel Hill Cafe proved to be the perfect backdrop for such diverse and spontaneous interactions, embodying everything a neighborhood bar should be. It was a night of unexpected friendships, hearty laughs, and culinary delights. Truly, The Cage isn’t just a bar; it’s a cornerstone of the community where anyone can feel like part of the neighborhood. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, you’re sure to find good food, great company, and maybe even a bit of unsolicited life advice, all served up with a smile at The Squirrel Hill Cafe.
Squirrel Hill Cafe  - April 2024 (AcrossPittsburgh) - -18
Squirrel Hill Cafe  - April 2024 (AcrossPittsburgh) - -04
Squirrel Hill Cafe  - April 2024 (AcrossPittsburgh) - -08
Squirrel Hill Cafe  - April 2024 (AcrossPittsburgh) - -27
Squirrel Hill Cafe  - April 2024 (AcrossPittsburgh) - -38
Squirrel Hill Cafe  - April 2024 (AcrossPittsburgh) - -41
Report this review Comments (0) | Was this review helpful? 0 0

User reviews

There are no user reviews for this listing.
Already have an account?
Ratings
Drinks
Are the drinks made well? Good pours?
Atmosphere
How much do you like the vibes?
Service
On the spot or mud in the ears?
Pricing
Good deals? Happy Hours? Specials?
Location
Easy or hard to get to? Parking?
Comments

Guides N' That - Hot

January 18, 2025
FeaturedHot

McCandless Crossing

Shops - Malls & Plazas
 
1
 
McCandless Crossing is a shopping plaza located along McKnight Rd. in McCandless T...
January 18, 2025
FeaturedHot

Pines Plaza

Shops - Malls & Plazas
 
1
 
Pines Plaza is a shopping plaza located along Perry Highway in the northern bounds...
September 30, 2024
Hot
 
 
Historical sign commemorating the 1987 North Hills Indians Football Team that went...
January 18, 2025
Hot
 
1
 
Monte Cello's Italian Restaurant  Monte Cello's Italian Restaurant is a long-stan...
January 18, 2025
FeaturedHot

Dive Bar & Grille (North Hills)

Food & Drink - Restaurants
 
1
 
Dive Bar & Grille (North Hills) is a multi-story restaurant and bar located along ...
January 18, 2025
FeaturedHot

Mcknight-Siebert Shopping Center

Shops - Malls & Plazas
 
1
 
McKnight-Siebert Shopping Center is a community center shopping plaza anchored by ...
January 18, 2025
Hot

West View Park Shopping Center

Shops - Malls & Plazas
 
1
 
West View Shopping Plaza is located in the heart of West View along Center Ave. ne...
January 18, 2025
FeaturedHot

Ross Park Mall

Shops - Malls & Plazas
 
1
 
Ross Park Mall, situated in Pittsburgh's North Hills within Ross Township, is a pr...
January 18, 2025
Hot

Waterworks Shopping Plaza

Shops - Malls & Plazas
 
 
Waterworks Shopping Plaza, located in the Fox Chapel area of Pittsburgh, Pennsylva...
January 18, 2025
FeaturedHot

Rico's Restaurant

Food & Drink - Restaurants
 
1
 
Rico's is a long-standing family-owned Italian restaurant and steakhouse featuring...

Guides N' That - Latest Reviews

DiPietro's Ristorante (OUT OF BUSINESS)
 
4.5
Matt De Reno
Matt De Reno
February 26, 2021
"DiPietro's is a long-standing favorite of ours. We particularly love the Sicilian-cut pizza. A distinguishing factor that sets DiPietro's apart..."
Ross Park Mall
 
4.0
Matt De Reno
Matt De Reno
March 04, 2021
" Ross Park Mall is not only a high-end retail shopping outlet destination for the North Hills but for the..."
Villa Fresh Italian Kitchen
 
3.0
Matt De Reno
Matt De Reno
March 12, 2021
" When you are shopping at the mall, who doesn't like a slice of pizza to hold the hunger over..."
El Campesino Mexican Restaurant
 
4.5
Matt De Reno
Matt De Reno
March 16, 2021
" During the Covid-19 lockdown in the late fall of 2020, we ordered a takeout dinner for four people. The..."
West View Park Shopping Center
 
2.6
Matt De Reno
Matt De Reno
March 19, 2021
" On the positive, West View shopping plaza sits in the heart, smack-dab in the middle of West View, which..."
Mcknight-Siebert Shopping Center
 
4.4
Matt De Reno
Matt De Reno
March 19, 2021
" As a resident of Ross Township, I will say I am at this shopping plaza quite a bit. I..."
Ross Towne Center
 
4.2
Matt De Reno
Matt De Reno
March 26, 2021
" Over the years many businesses have come and gone at Ross Towne Center, but the management has done a..."
Mt Nebo Pointe
 
4.8
Matt De Reno
Matt De Reno
March 26, 2021
" Mt. Nebo Pointe is nicely located for the folks in the North Hills living in Ohio Township, Ben Avon..."
Pines Plaza
 
4.0
Matt De Reno
Matt De Reno
March 26, 2021
" Pines Plaza could use a fresh coat of paint, but who are we to complain? There is a wonderful..."
North Hills Village
 
4.0
Matt De Reno
Matt De Reno
March 26, 2021
" There is nothing spectacular about shopping at North Hills village, however, there is a local photography shop of note..."